Showing posts with label best-before date. Show all posts
Showing posts with label best-before date. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 25, 2016

Hazards of a long supply chain - sale of time-expired product

Poor old Fonterra!  The New Zealand dairy giant is in the news again for a problem with milk powder in China, but this time it could have been any food company.  Its product has been on-sold several times, and time-expired milk powder has been repackaged and sold at a discounted rate.

I haven't been able to find out whether the original powder packaging was marked with a "Best before" date, or a "Use by" date and these terms are not used in China.  According to National Standard GB7718-2011, the General Rules for the Labeling of Prepackaged Foods, in China, the labeling consist of production date and date of minimum durability.

Clearly, Fonterra is blameless in this case, and, with a long supply chain, it is difficult for the company to control what happens to its product.


The obvious concern in China, beyond any illegal activity, is the potential hazard to the consumer.


Can time-expired milk powder be hazardous to the consumer?  In my opinion, this is highly unlikely.  Properly packed and stored milk powder will keep for years - bacteria will not grow in the very low water activity in the powder.  However, repackaging offers the possibility of contamination.  The most likely issue is that the powder may become oxidised, leading to taste defects.


So, is this a big deal?  Yes - the consumer is entitled to receive food products in good condition and not be sold inferior goods, and this includes not receiving perfectly safe but time-expired products.

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

Mould, the consumer and the retailer

Many searchers of this blog have asked "Will spoiled food make you sick?"  I have commented on this before.

Over the last few weeks, I have purchased two blocks of cheddar cheese from a large supermarket chain in New Zealand.  When they were opened, both blocks were found to have a few mould colonies growing along the edges and at the corners.  This became apparent when the plastic film was peeled back.

Do these mould colonies represent a health hazard?  According to Dr. John Pitt, Aspergillus flavus is unable to produce aflatoxin at refrigerator conditions, so it is unlikely that there is a health hazard if the cheese is eaten.  I just cut the mould off, together with a bit extra to avoid eating cheese with changed flavour resulting from the mould growth. 

My wife, who is obsessed with "food going out of it's date stamp" suggested that the cheese might be old,  ("Well, that's why you buy mature cheese, dear"), but the best-before date stamp was mid-2013.

I wrote, complaining to the supermarket chain and pointing out that there were probably only two reasons  that these blocks of cheese could have had mould growth inside the pack - the cheese was packed under poor hygiene conditions in which mould spores were able to contaminate the block, and maybe the film had been pulled too tightly at the edges and corners, increasing the gas permeability and allowing air to penetrate the pack to allow the strictly aerobic moulds to grow.

No harm, no foul you might say.  But the consumer is entitled to buy safe, wholesome food and to have mouldy cheese only when mould is part of the normally accepted description of the cheese, such as Brie, Camembert and Roquefort.  Cheddar is not mould-ripened.

What I found interesting about this, besides the technical issue, was that the supermarket chain completely ignored my complaint, not even sending some sort of "We are looking into it" brush-off.  Do they not care about consumer perceptions of their stores, or does this happen so often that they feel it is 'normal'?

Thursday, June 25, 2009

Do consumers understand “Use-by” and “Best-before” dates?

I think that many consumers don't understand these package marks.

I recently received a message from a very distressed reader. She'll recognise herself, but I'm sure she won't mind my writing this.

The reader had a 16-month-old son and had fed him a jar of organic apple, pear, blueberry and blackberry with vitamin C. The young man had eaten it all and was apparently bouncing around, as 16-month-olds tend to do. The jar and contents appeared normal, with a suitable vacuum in the headspace.

After the meal was over, the mother looked at the jar and found the “best before date was 29th July 2008!” (her exclamation mark). She went on: “I am very concerned that he could get Botulism from this - is there a way that I could get the remains of the food in the jar tested to make sure that he is not in any danger? Please, I am happy to pay for this and your time.

“I have spoken to a few people and they have all said that we will have to wait the 10 days to be on the safe side. Is there anything else I can do to protect my son? or help to prevent anything really nasty making him sick from this?”

This mother was obviously very frightened. Her concern was triggered by the best before date, which is an advisory to the consumer about quality. Chemical changes can occur slowly in cans or jars of food during storage. These changes may be accelerated if the food is exposed to sunlight or high temperatures. These changes may make the food less appetising, such as giving a "cardboardy" or flat, oxidized taste. The changes are not harmful. If the food is outside the Best Before date, it does not necessarily indicate that it is unsafe to eat, though that might be the case with something like ham or egg salad, which are much more perishable.

I didn’t have any further information on the product, but would expect that it would have been processed either as an acid food (pH less than 4.6) and pasteurised, perhaps hot-filled, or processed as a low acid food (pH above 4.6) and thus be given a 12D process (sterilised). In either case, Clostridium botulinum toxin would not be produced. Any changes occurring after the best before date would be quality deterioration only, not safety issues. There are several other points to come out of this discussion, but I'll cover them in a future posting.

Extrapolating from this, it is probable that consumers and perhaps retailers don’t fully understand the significance of “use-by” dates. I have certainly seen products in supermarket display cabinets with the original “use-by” date covered with a second label bearing a later date. The latter is illegal in New Zealand.*

And the boy? I had a message from his Mum today - this is the 11th day since he ate the food, which had actually been made in 2006. He didn't get sick and is now toddling around the home at high speed. Well, some food stories have happy endings!


* You can find an article "Date Marking - Standard 1.2.5" on the NZFSA website at www.nzfsa.govt.nz/