Showing posts with label Pasteurization. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pasteurization. Show all posts
Sunday, March 27, 2011
Poor Understanding - Raw Milk in New Zealand
Last week, I read an interesting article by Jill Galloway in the Manawatu Standard entitled "Selling milk as it was meant to be". The story was about the increasing sales of unpasteurised and non-homogenised milk at the farm gate. Unfortunately, the author and/or her interviewees made a number of errors.
Under New Zealand law, sales of raw milk from the farm gate have been permitted for several decades. All other milk and milk products must be pasteurised or given an approved alternative treatment. Section 11A of the Food Act 1981 allows for producers to sell up to five litres of raw milk at any one time from their farm gates to people who intend to consume it themselves, or to provide it to their families. However, the milk must be harvested under an approved Risk Management Programme under the Animal Products Act 1999.
So if farmers follow the rules, there should be no problem about safety.
However the article went on to express some strange views.
For example: "People believe in the integrity of food. People want to know where it comes from. Processing destroys dairy products".
Or how about: (Farmers) "are up against rules, regulations and science".
But my favourite was: "Before processed milk, there was no heart disease. Homogenisation means the fat particles are small enough to be ingested, not digested, and go straight through to the blood and arteries," Ms M. says. She thinks homogenisation began because people thought the fat on the top of milk was bad and they did not want to see it.
Hang on a minute. If Ms M. is correct, then the dairy companies are actually delivering what consumers are demanding.
Second place goes to Farmer C: "When it is pasteurised, the milk becomes dead. People don't want to be eating or drinking dead stuff."
So you never had a steak, Mr. C?
I guess I should not poke fun at these people, who genuinely believe that their product is better than pasteurised milk. And indeed, they are producing their product according to the NZFSA regulations. But it does worry me that people can be so smart in some aspects of their lives but authoritatively make such ignorant statements.
Under New Zealand law, sales of raw milk from the farm gate have been permitted for several decades. All other milk and milk products must be pasteurised or given an approved alternative treatment. Section 11A of the Food Act 1981 allows for producers to sell up to five litres of raw milk at any one time from their farm gates to people who intend to consume it themselves, or to provide it to their families. However, the milk must be harvested under an approved Risk Management Programme under the Animal Products Act 1999.
So if farmers follow the rules, there should be no problem about safety.
However the article went on to express some strange views.
For example: "People believe in the integrity of food. People want to know where it comes from. Processing destroys dairy products".
Or how about: (Farmers) "are up against rules, regulations and science".
But my favourite was: "Before processed milk, there was no heart disease. Homogenisation means the fat particles are small enough to be ingested, not digested, and go straight through to the blood and arteries," Ms M. says. She thinks homogenisation began because people thought the fat on the top of milk was bad and they did not want to see it.
Hang on a minute. If Ms M. is correct, then the dairy companies are actually delivering what consumers are demanding.
Second place goes to Farmer C: "When it is pasteurised, the milk becomes dead. People don't want to be eating or drinking dead stuff."
So you never had a steak, Mr. C?
I guess I should not poke fun at these people, who genuinely believe that their product is better than pasteurised milk. And indeed, they are producing their product according to the NZFSA regulations. But it does worry me that people can be so smart in some aspects of their lives but authoritatively make such ignorant statements.
Friday, December 17, 2010
Why do people buy insurance?
Do you sometimes think "Why do I keep paying insurance premiums for my car, boat, house, personal liability, camera etc? I hardly ever make a claim". In all the years I have been paying premiums, I have only once made a claim on my car insurance, and that was when one of the local semi-evolved simians stole it and drove it into a ditch. Would you consider not insuring your house? Would you be able to continue with business as usual if your offices burned down? The chances of making a claim and getting some of the premiums back are quite small.
The probable reason we continue to pay is that it gives us peace of mind, knowing that if we do smash the car into a BMW or Rolls Royce, we won't be bankrupted by the repair bills for the other car. We can drive, secure in the knowledge that we have that one covered.
Pasteurisation of milk is insurance and free. A mild heat treatment kills all the pathogens that might have got into the milk during milking and transport, leaving the nutritional value essentially unchanged. Why would you even consider drinking raw milk or eating raw cheese, knowing that there is a small chance that it could result in illness that would change your life or that of your family for ever? There has been plenty written about the dangers of Escherichia coli O157:H7 and other STECs, so I'm not going to go over it again here. (See other posts on E. coli by clicking the E. coli label at the RHS of this blog).
Please, this Christmas season, if you really want to eat and drink raw milk products, you can make an informed choice. But don't give these products to children - they don't have that choice and a dose of E. coli O157:H7 can lead to HUS, which will probably ruin the rest of their lives.
The probable reason we continue to pay is that it gives us peace of mind, knowing that if we do smash the car into a BMW or Rolls Royce, we won't be bankrupted by the repair bills for the other car. We can drive, secure in the knowledge that we have that one covered.
Pasteurisation of milk is insurance and free. A mild heat treatment kills all the pathogens that might have got into the milk during milking and transport, leaving the nutritional value essentially unchanged. Why would you even consider drinking raw milk or eating raw cheese, knowing that there is a small chance that it could result in illness that would change your life or that of your family for ever? There has been plenty written about the dangers of Escherichia coli O157:H7 and other STECs, so I'm not going to go over it again here. (See other posts on E. coli by clicking the E. coli label at the RHS of this blog).
Please, this Christmas season, if you really want to eat and drink raw milk products, you can make an informed choice. But don't give these products to children - they don't have that choice and a dose of E. coli O157:H7 can lead to HUS, which will probably ruin the rest of their lives.
Wednesday, December 2, 2009
Raw milk and people with influence
It’s happened again! Bill Marler quotes a Washington State Department of Agriculture News Release, reporting that three recent Escherichia coli infections in Washington have been linked to drinking raw, unpasteurised milk. The Washington state departments of Health and Agriculture have put out new warnings about the risks of consuming unpasteurised milk and milk products.
All the patients involved have reported drinking raw milk from the same supplier. Though no E. coli have been found in the most recent batch of product tested, the Washington State Department of Agriculture did find in the dairy the same strain involved in one of the illnesses.
Bill Marler, Doug Powell and I have all written on many occasions about the hazards of consuming raw milk. Doug has emphasized that personal freedom is all very fine, but young children cannot exercise freedom of choice. They are often the ones made ill by bacteria carried in raw milk. If you think that we are a bit over the top on this issue, have a look at the You Tube clip of Barb Kowalcyk talking about her son, Kevin, who contracted haemorrhagic E. coli infection.
http://www.marlerblog.com/2009/12/articles/legal-cases/perfectly-healthy-to-dead-in-twelve-days-hemolytic-uremic-syndrome/
A few days ago, Tamati Coffey was shown on TVNZ’s “Breakfast” programme milking a cow and then drinking the milk. No real problem there. The show’s hosts, Pippa Wetzell and Paul Henry then discussed the merits of drinking raw milk. Typically, Paul reckoned he wouldn’t touch the stuff, but I was surprised when Pippa, who recently had a new baby, argued that drinking raw milk is good for you. Many people watch this programme every day and there must be a proportion of those who are mothers of young children. Judging by the daily feedback, viewers hang on every word the presenters utter. I have to admit that I too enjoy the quick repartee of Paul and Pippa, but her throwaway line could easily influence parents to feed raw milk products to their children, with potentially disastrous consequences.
Perhaps television presenters should be a bit more careful when it comes to expressing views on the safety of foods – they are not trained in food safety. As they said in the post-war years when I was a lad “Careless talk costs lives”. It’s just as true today.
All the patients involved have reported drinking raw milk from the same supplier. Though no E. coli have been found in the most recent batch of product tested, the Washington State Department of Agriculture did find in the dairy the same strain involved in one of the illnesses.
Bill Marler, Doug Powell and I have all written on many occasions about the hazards of consuming raw milk. Doug has emphasized that personal freedom is all very fine, but young children cannot exercise freedom of choice. They are often the ones made ill by bacteria carried in raw milk. If you think that we are a bit over the top on this issue, have a look at the You Tube clip of Barb Kowalcyk talking about her son, Kevin, who contracted haemorrhagic E. coli infection.
http://www.marlerblog.com/2009/12/articles/legal-cases/perfectly-healthy-to-dead-in-twelve-days-hemolytic-uremic-syndrome/
A few days ago, Tamati Coffey was shown on TVNZ’s “Breakfast” programme milking a cow and then drinking the milk. No real problem there. The show’s hosts, Pippa Wetzell and Paul Henry then discussed the merits of drinking raw milk. Typically, Paul reckoned he wouldn’t touch the stuff, but I was surprised when Pippa, who recently had a new baby, argued that drinking raw milk is good for you. Many people watch this programme every day and there must be a proportion of those who are mothers of young children. Judging by the daily feedback, viewers hang on every word the presenters utter. I have to admit that I too enjoy the quick repartee of Paul and Pippa, but her throwaway line could easily influence parents to feed raw milk products to their children, with potentially disastrous consequences.
Perhaps television presenters should be a bit more careful when it comes to expressing views on the safety of foods – they are not trained in food safety. As they said in the post-war years when I was a lad “Careless talk costs lives”. It’s just as true today.
Tuesday, October 20, 2009
New technology to double avocado shelf life: NZL FOODweek Online Main Features Page
New Zealand FOODweek Online published an article on high pressure processing (HPP) of avocado to extend shelf life. The link is shown below:
New technology to double avocado shelf life: NZL FOODweek Online Main Features Page
HPP has been used for some time, particularly in Japan for cold pasteurisation. In a future blog article, I will write about HPP and explain how it works and how it can be applied to foods.
New technology to double avocado shelf life: NZL FOODweek Online Main Features Page
HPP has been used for some time, particularly in Japan for cold pasteurisation. In a future blog article, I will write about HPP and explain how it works and how it can be applied to foods.
Wednesday, August 13, 2008
Coming soon to a store in New Zealand?
I have written several times about the potential hazards of consuming raw milk and raw milk products. Search this site using keyword “raw milk” for other posts.
Currently the New Zealand food regulations allow only three particular hard and very hard Swiss cheeses, extra-hard Parmesan style grating cheeses like Grana Padano, Pamigiano Reggiano, Romano, Asiago and Montasio and the semi-hard Roquefort cheese. Local manufacture of similar products is not permitted. See www.nzfsa.govt.nz/publications/media-releases/2008/2008-08-07-raw-milk.htm
The New Zealand Food Safety Authority is now asking for submissions on a proposed framework for the manufacture, importation and sale of raw milk products. See www.nzfsa.govt.nz?consultation
Aficionados of raw milk cheeses will applaud this move. It is quite possible to produce safe cheeses without pasteurization of milk and, provided that the resulting products are safe, manufacturers and consumers should be given the opportunity to make and taste them. However, the process requires strict control of animal health and rigorous processing hygiene - good regulations and inspection will be needed.
Even the cheesemakers are divided on the desirability of permitting the manufacture of raw milk cheeses. One, quoted in the Otago Daily Times on 11th August 2008 said that cheeses made from non-pasteurised milk could be “lovely", but they could also be “bloody awful stuff". The explanation for this is that pasteurized milk contains only heat resistant bacteria, such as some Streptococcus species and sporeformers. The cheese is made by inoculating the pasteurized milk with known cultures of "starter bacteria", which will produce lactic acid to coagulate the milk protein and produce a curd. When cheese is made from unpasteurized milk, the bacteria present in the raw milk may grow beside the starters. This can result in more complex flavours, but can also lead to variation between batches. Unfortunately, the non-starter bacteria can sometimes cause disease, such as salmonellosis and campylobacteriosis, or may produce toxins, such as staphylococcal enterotoxin.
Softer raw milk cheeses represent a greater risk to the consumer because of their higher water activity, which allows some pathogens to survive and grow. Control over the milk production and handling and the cheesemaking process itself must therefore be absolutely spot-on for these products.
Under the proposed framework, raw milk products would be categorised according to the risks they present. Category one products would pose no greater food safety concerns than pasteurised cheeses, such as Parmesan-style raw milk cheeses. Category two products would pose a low risk for the general population but vulnerable consumers with reduced immunity might be at greater risk. Products in this category would include semi-hard Roquefort. Category three would cover those raw milk products that cannot currently be produced to an acceptable level of safety for the general population. (As far as I know, this category has not yet been defined more closely).
Assuming that the consultation process approves the proposed framework, locally produced raw milk cheeses and other raw milk products may soon hit the delicatessen and specialty store shelves. It may be too soon to expect these products to be sold in supermarkets.
Would I eat raw milk cheese? Probably not until the framework were shown to be working well and the suppliers had built up a record of selling safe products. Even then, I would eat only the hard or semi-hard varieties. Would I give it to my little granddaughter? Not a chance! Raw milk products are not for little children or the immunocompromised.
Currently the New Zealand food regulations allow only three particular hard and very hard Swiss cheeses, extra-hard Parmesan style grating cheeses like Grana Padano, Pamigiano Reggiano, Romano, Asiago and Montasio and the semi-hard Roquefort cheese. Local manufacture of similar products is not permitted. See www.nzfsa.govt.nz/publications/media-releases/2008/2008-08-07-raw-milk.htm
The New Zealand Food Safety Authority is now asking for submissions on a proposed framework for the manufacture, importation and sale of raw milk products. See www.nzfsa.govt.nz?consultation
Aficionados of raw milk cheeses will applaud this move. It is quite possible to produce safe cheeses without pasteurization of milk and, provided that the resulting products are safe, manufacturers and consumers should be given the opportunity to make and taste them. However, the process requires strict control of animal health and rigorous processing hygiene - good regulations and inspection will be needed.
Even the cheesemakers are divided on the desirability of permitting the manufacture of raw milk cheeses. One, quoted in the Otago Daily Times on 11th August 2008 said that cheeses made from non-pasteurised milk could be “lovely", but they could also be “bloody awful stuff". The explanation for this is that pasteurized milk contains only heat resistant bacteria, such as some Streptococcus species and sporeformers. The cheese is made by inoculating the pasteurized milk with known cultures of "starter bacteria", which will produce lactic acid to coagulate the milk protein and produce a curd. When cheese is made from unpasteurized milk, the bacteria present in the raw milk may grow beside the starters. This can result in more complex flavours, but can also lead to variation between batches. Unfortunately, the non-starter bacteria can sometimes cause disease, such as salmonellosis and campylobacteriosis, or may produce toxins, such as staphylococcal enterotoxin.
Softer raw milk cheeses represent a greater risk to the consumer because of their higher water activity, which allows some pathogens to survive and grow. Control over the milk production and handling and the cheesemaking process itself must therefore be absolutely spot-on for these products.
Under the proposed framework, raw milk products would be categorised according to the risks they present. Category one products would pose no greater food safety concerns than pasteurised cheeses, such as Parmesan-style raw milk cheeses. Category two products would pose a low risk for the general population but vulnerable consumers with reduced immunity might be at greater risk. Products in this category would include semi-hard Roquefort. Category three would cover those raw milk products that cannot currently be produced to an acceptable level of safety for the general population. (As far as I know, this category has not yet been defined more closely).
Assuming that the consultation process approves the proposed framework, locally produced raw milk cheeses and other raw milk products may soon hit the delicatessen and specialty store shelves. It may be too soon to expect these products to be sold in supermarkets.
Would I eat raw milk cheese? Probably not until the framework were shown to be working well and the suppliers had built up a record of selling safe products. Even then, I would eat only the hard or semi-hard varieties. Would I give it to my little granddaughter? Not a chance! Raw milk products are not for little children or the immunocompromised.
Thursday, June 5, 2008
It had to happen!
In the USA, the argument about raw milk still rages. We now see the spectacle of lawyers claiming that consumers are being deprived of their rights to choose their food, while others sue the suppliers for selling dangerous milk.
The raw milk lobby claims that pasteurization robs the milk of its nutritional value and the natural enzymes that help the human digestive system. I am not aware of any scientific evidence to support this. They also vociferously claim that pasteurization kills the “good bacteria”. The zealous consumers claim that their rights are being trampled if they are prevented from buying the product. The regulators point to the dangers of consuming raw milk, such as the diseases caused by Salmonella, Campylobacter, Escherichia coli, Listeria and others, a point conveniently ignored by the raw milk proponents.
The hazards of consuming raw milk have been known for a long time. In Ontario around 1900, over 10% of all childhood tuberculosis was thought to be caused by unpasteurized milk. The rate of tuberculosis infection and many other milk-borne diseases in children fell dramatically after enactment of a law in 1938 requiring milk to be pasteurized; this was hailed as a major achievement.
The fact is that between 1998 and 2005, a total of 45 outbreaks resulting in more than 1,000 illnesses, 104 hospitalizations and two deaths due to raw milk or soft raw milk cheese were reported to the Centres for Disease Control and Prevention. There have been more recent, high-profile cases. Pathogens were found in 13 percent of bulk tank raw milk samples by a survey of Pennsylvania dairy farms in 2006. In California, 2008, new regulations set a limit of 10 coliforms per millilitre of raw milk. Raw milk suppliers maintain that the regulation will put them out of business, which suggests to me that they feel unable to meet this specification. But it's the same standard used for pasteurized milk. <For an explanation of the use of coliforms, see "Is hamburger a greater risk for E. coli" this blog, posted 3rd May 2008>.
Farmers who are selling raw milk are able to charge a significant premium for their product and understandably wish to continue supply. However, nothing comes without a price, and the right to sell a particular food product imposes certain responsibilities. Some American consumers have contracted serious disease from drinking raw milk. Unfortunately, children have no choice in the source of their milk and several have suffered haemolytic uremic syndrome (which has a 90% mortality rate without treament) and a number have required kidney transplants. The suppliers are now being sued.
In New Zealand, NZFSA has recently renewed its warning to consumers about raw milk cheeses, which have recently been approved for sale here. People with compromised immune systems, the elderly or pregnant women are urged to avoid these products.
The raw milk lobby claims that pasteurization robs the milk of its nutritional value and the natural enzymes that help the human digestive system. I am not aware of any scientific evidence to support this. They also vociferously claim that pasteurization kills the “good bacteria”. The zealous consumers claim that their rights are being trampled if they are prevented from buying the product. The regulators point to the dangers of consuming raw milk, such as the diseases caused by Salmonella, Campylobacter, Escherichia coli, Listeria and others, a point conveniently ignored by the raw milk proponents.
The hazards of consuming raw milk have been known for a long time. In Ontario around 1900, over 10% of all childhood tuberculosis was thought to be caused by unpasteurized milk. The rate of tuberculosis infection and many other milk-borne diseases in children fell dramatically after enactment of a law in 1938 requiring milk to be pasteurized; this was hailed as a major achievement.
The fact is that between 1998 and 2005, a total of 45 outbreaks resulting in more than 1,000 illnesses, 104 hospitalizations and two deaths due to raw milk or soft raw milk cheese were reported to the Centres for Disease Control and Prevention. There have been more recent, high-profile cases. Pathogens were found in 13 percent of bulk tank raw milk samples by a survey of Pennsylvania dairy farms in 2006. In California, 2008, new regulations set a limit of 10 coliforms per millilitre of raw milk. Raw milk suppliers maintain that the regulation will put them out of business, which suggests to me that they feel unable to meet this specification. But it's the same standard used for pasteurized milk. <For an explanation of the use of coliforms, see "Is hamburger a greater risk for E. coli" this blog, posted 3rd May 2008>.
Farmers who are selling raw milk are able to charge a significant premium for their product and understandably wish to continue supply. However, nothing comes without a price, and the right to sell a particular food product imposes certain responsibilities. Some American consumers have contracted serious disease from drinking raw milk. Unfortunately, children have no choice in the source of their milk and several have suffered haemolytic uremic syndrome (which has a 90% mortality rate without treament) and a number have required kidney transplants. The suppliers are now being sued.
In New Zealand, NZFSA has recently renewed its warning to consumers about raw milk cheeses, which have recently been approved for sale here. People with compromised immune systems, the elderly or pregnant women are urged to avoid these products.
Tuesday, January 22, 2008
Hazardous Home-made Ice Cream
We’ve probably all eaten and enjoyed home-made ice cream at some time in our lives. It can be great fun for kids to help Mum make it during the summer holidays.
During the recent summer holiday (Southern Hemisphere), my neighbour gave me a recipe for making ice cream. It seemed simple enough – just combining eggs and cream, vanilla and sugar and then freezing it, stirring at intervals. “The children just love it”. There was no mention of pasteurization, which made me uncomfortable.
I looked for “Ice cream home made” on Google and found many recipes, some of which used eggs. Some included heating steps, some didn’t. This is worrying.
Eggs can potentially be infected with Salmonella during formation in the hen. External contamination can also occur, which may be transferred to the egg contents when the shell is cracked. The egg industry has procedures in place to minimize these risks and commercial egg pulp is pasteurized. This is a fairly delicate balance between providing sufficient heat to kill pathogenic bacteria and not causing the egg proteins to denature.
If you are going to make ice cream at home this summer, I recommend that you either use a recipe that does not call for eggs, or that you use a process that heats the eggs. A typical recipe can be found at:
http://www.cooks.com/rec/doc/0,1613,150189-248198,00.html
where the following instruction is given: “In heavy 3 quart saucepan with wire whisk, combine sugar, flour and salt. Beat in milk and eggs until well blended. Cook over medium low heat, stirring frequently, until mixture thickens and coats spoon, about 30 to 45 minutes. (Do not boil or mixture will curdle.) Cover surface with plastic wrap; cool completely, about 3 hours”.
The temperature of the egg mix needs to get high enough to kill Salmonella bacteria if they are present. This can be achieved by heating the mix to 80C and holding it for 15 seconds.
During the recent summer holiday (Southern Hemisphere), my neighbour gave me a recipe for making ice cream. It seemed simple enough – just combining eggs and cream, vanilla and sugar and then freezing it, stirring at intervals. “The children just love it”. There was no mention of pasteurization, which made me uncomfortable.
I looked for “Ice cream home made” on Google and found many recipes, some of which used eggs. Some included heating steps, some didn’t. This is worrying.
Eggs can potentially be infected with Salmonella during formation in the hen. External contamination can also occur, which may be transferred to the egg contents when the shell is cracked. The egg industry has procedures in place to minimize these risks and commercial egg pulp is pasteurized. This is a fairly delicate balance between providing sufficient heat to kill pathogenic bacteria and not causing the egg proteins to denature.
If you are going to make ice cream at home this summer, I recommend that you either use a recipe that does not call for eggs, or that you use a process that heats the eggs. A typical recipe can be found at:
http://www.cooks.com/rec/doc/0,1613,150189-248198,00.html
where the following instruction is given: “In heavy 3 quart saucepan with wire whisk, combine sugar, flour and salt. Beat in milk and eggs until well blended. Cook over medium low heat, stirring frequently, until mixture thickens and coats spoon, about 30 to 45 minutes. (Do not boil or mixture will curdle.) Cover surface with plastic wrap; cool completely, about 3 hours”.
The temperature of the egg mix needs to get high enough to kill Salmonella bacteria if they are present. This can be achieved by heating the mix to 80C and holding it for 15 seconds.
Sunday, June 3, 2007
Free Choice or Safety of the Population?
Governments and regulators are always in a difficult position. Do they allow total freedom of choice, or does their responsibility to the population require them to make restrictive decisions based on the greater good of the people? The government then performs a balancing act, running the risk of being labelled as Big Brother (or at least Nanny Government) or as being irresponsible. For example, should we all be allowed to use any chemical we can obtain to relieve the monotony of our daily lives, or should there be regulations to control the use of mind-altering substances and thus protect us from ourselves? If we allow unfettered use of any substance and thus maintain personal freedom, how do we protect the innocent - those who are too young or too poorly educated to know that these materials may be harmful?
Most people would probably come down on the side of some restrictions for the use of drugs, though some would argue for freedom of choice. The same applies to the sale and consumption of raw milk and raw milk products.
I have discussed raw milk before in this blog. I might have left it at that, but the New Zealand Government, in the form of the New Zealand Food Safety Authority has now called for submissions on a proposal to permit direct imports of Roquefort, a soft raw milk cheese made in France, and extra hard Parmesan-style raw milk cheeses Grana Padano, Pamigiano Reggiano, Romano, Asiago and Montasio. An extensive programme of risk assessment has already been undertaken and the Authority is now consulting with industry groups.
This development may lead some members of the community to believe that Big Brother has been wrong all along and is now backing down. Extra hard cheeses have a low water activity* of about 0.693 that prevents the growth of most bacteria. Soft cheeses, such as Brie, Camembert and Roquefort have much higher water activities and thus may permit the growth of pathogens such as Listeria monocytogenes (see post To Pasteurize or not? - 10th December 2006). The truth is that cheeses made from raw milk are not as safe as those made with pasteurized milk.
*Water activity is a measure of the ability of water to take part in biological and chemical reactions. It is measured as a ratio of the partial vapour pressure of the food to that of pure water. That sounds complicated, (it's not) but it results in a scale of water activity running from 0 to 1. Generally speaking, the lower the water activity, the harder it is for micro-organisms to grow. Water activity in foods can be controlled by salts and sugars. So we can formulate food to have a particular water activity and thus preserve the food.
Most people would probably come down on the side of some restrictions for the use of drugs, though some would argue for freedom of choice. The same applies to the sale and consumption of raw milk and raw milk products.
I have discussed raw milk before in this blog. I might have left it at that, but the New Zealand Government, in the form of the New Zealand Food Safety Authority has now called for submissions on a proposal to permit direct imports of Roquefort, a soft raw milk cheese made in France, and extra hard Parmesan-style raw milk cheeses Grana Padano, Pamigiano Reggiano, Romano, Asiago and Montasio. An extensive programme of risk assessment has already been undertaken and the Authority is now consulting with industry groups.
This development may lead some members of the community to believe that Big Brother has been wrong all along and is now backing down. Extra hard cheeses have a low water activity* of about 0.693 that prevents the growth of most bacteria. Soft cheeses, such as Brie, Camembert and Roquefort have much higher water activities and thus may permit the growth of pathogens such as Listeria monocytogenes (see post To Pasteurize or not? - 10th December 2006). The truth is that cheeses made from raw milk are not as safe as those made with pasteurized milk.
European Community (EC) legislation sets microbiological, food safety and process hygiene criteria that reduce the risks in consumption of raw milk cheeses. NZFSA has recommended that if these products are to be directly imported and ultimately manufactured in New Zealand, additional risk mitigation measures should be introduced:
• 100% verification of certificates attesting that the relevant EC standards have been met
• continuing monitoring of products to check for E. coli levels, which can indicate unsafe manufacturing conditions leading to faecal contamination of the cheese.
It is expected that leaflets, posters and point of sale brochures will be required to educate the consumers on the risks of eating cheeses made from unpasteurized milk and that labelling of the products will be mandatory. Yet another acronym has been added to our lexicon: YOPI - Young, Old, Pregnant or Immunocompromised. This group of the population should not consume raw milk products.*Water activity is a measure of the ability of water to take part in biological and chemical reactions. It is measured as a ratio of the partial vapour pressure of the food to that of pure water. That sounds complicated, (it's not) but it results in a scale of water activity running from 0 to 1. Generally speaking, the lower the water activity, the harder it is for micro-organisms to grow. Water activity in foods can be controlled by salts and sugars. So we can formulate food to have a particular water activity and thus preserve the food.
Sunday, March 18, 2007
Yet more on unpasteurized milk
This post was updated on 30th April, 2007.
In the previous post I mentioned the potential for contraction or spread of disease that could result from the consumption of raw milk or products made from unpasteurized milk. In that case the consumers may have contracted salmonellosis from the milk.
This week the Grey Bruce Health Unit in Ontario, Canada, issued a press statement, warning pregnant women to avoid consumption of raw milk and unpasteurized dairy products. The warning was issued to help prevent listeriosis infection in newborn babies. The original release can be found at:
http://www.publichealthgreybruce.on.ca/HOME/NewsEvents/2007/Mar/2006Mar14_Infant-Listeriosis.htm
Non-pregnant humans are highly resistant to the infection, though if they do become infected, the symptoms can be very serious, including meningitis and sepsis (invasion of the blood or tissues by bacteria or their toxins). Pregnant women may contract Listeriosis, but show no serious symptoms beyond mild influenza-like signs. Their foetus, however, may be infected, resulting in abortion or stillbirth. If the infant is infected during delivery, symptoms of meningitis begin 1 to 4 weeks later.
The Grey Bruce Health Unit news release stated that it had received a laboratory-confirmed report of an infant who contracted the disease. The most likely source of infection was said to be the mother’s consumption of raw milk cheese.
The release went on to say that pregnant women are at a 17 times higher risk than the general population of contracting the disease.
My personal and professional opinion is that any perceived benefits of drinking raw milk are far outweighed by the risks, both to the individual and to others in the same household. This is supported by scientific evidence: In the last decade the Center for Disease Control and Prevention has documented more than a thousand cases of food-borne illness and two deaths, all caused by unpasteurized dairy products. I have advised my pregnant daughter-in-law to avoid raw milk and raw milk products.
In the previous post I mentioned the potential for contraction or spread of disease that could result from the consumption of raw milk or products made from unpasteurized milk. In that case the consumers may have contracted salmonellosis from the milk.
This week the Grey Bruce Health Unit in Ontario, Canada, issued a press statement, warning pregnant women to avoid consumption of raw milk and unpasteurized dairy products. The warning was issued to help prevent listeriosis infection in newborn babies. The original release can be found at:
http://www.publichealthgreybruce.on.ca/HOME/NewsEvents/2007/Mar/2006Mar14_Infant-Listeriosis.htm
Non-pregnant humans are highly resistant to the infection, though if they do become infected, the symptoms can be very serious, including meningitis and sepsis (invasion of the blood or tissues by bacteria or their toxins). Pregnant women may contract Listeriosis, but show no serious symptoms beyond mild influenza-like signs. Their foetus, however, may be infected, resulting in abortion or stillbirth. If the infant is infected during delivery, symptoms of meningitis begin 1 to 4 weeks later.
The Grey Bruce Health Unit news release stated that it had received a laboratory-confirmed report of an infant who contracted the disease. The most likely source of infection was said to be the mother’s consumption of raw milk cheese.
The release went on to say that pregnant women are at a 17 times higher risk than the general population of contracting the disease.
My personal and professional opinion is that any perceived benefits of drinking raw milk are far outweighed by the risks, both to the individual and to others in the same household. This is supported by scientific evidence: In the last decade the Center for Disease Control and Prevention has documented more than a thousand cases of food-borne illness and two deaths, all caused by unpasteurized dairy products. I have advised my pregnant daughter-in-law to avoid raw milk and raw milk products.
Sunday, March 4, 2007
More on unpasteurized milk
The arguments about the desirability or otherwise of drinking unpasteurized milk continue. It seems that its proponents will hear nothing said against the practice; many scientists and doctors provide comment, often supported by case studies, that suggest that there are significant and serious risks associated with drinking unpasteurized milk.
The following report was posted recently on the Food Safety Network mailing list on behalf of Doug Powell of Kansas State University:
Begins
http://www.wdbj7.com/Global/story.asp?S=6170552&nav=S6aK
WDBJ7 News
HARRISBURG, Pa. -- The Pennsylvania Health Department is, according to this story, warning consumers not to drink raw milk from a York County dairy farm after confirming that two people who drank it last month were sickened by salmonella.Health Secretary Calvin Johnson was cited as saying the state Agriculture Department has also obtained three samples from Stump Acres Dairy in New Salem that tested positive for salmonella.
Ends
Of course, the facts that two consumers of the product contracted salmonellosis and that samples taken from the dairy tested positive do not prove that the unpasteurized milk was the source, though detection of the same serotype in patients and the milk would be very strong evidence. However, the correlation between raw milk consumption and illness is hard to ignore.
There are sometimes suggestions that the pasteurization process is too severe. The process was originally designed to eliminate Salmonella, but was later modified to be slightly more rigorous to ensure that Coxiella burnetti (a rickettsia-like organism which is the cause of Q-fever - a febrile disease of man and which sometimes has serious sequellae), was eliminated. There is currently some investigation of the time/temperature relationships in milk pasteurization to see if there is a possibility of making the process less severe.
The following report was posted recently on the Food Safety Network mailing list on behalf of Doug Powell of Kansas State University:
Begins
http://www.wdbj7.com/Global/story.asp?S=6170552&nav=S6aK
WDBJ7 News
HARRISBURG, Pa. -- The Pennsylvania Health Department is, according to this story, warning consumers not to drink raw milk from a York County dairy farm after confirming that two people who drank it last month were sickened by salmonella.Health Secretary Calvin Johnson was cited as saying the state Agriculture Department has also obtained three samples from Stump Acres Dairy in New Salem that tested positive for salmonella.
Ends
Of course, the facts that two consumers of the product contracted salmonellosis and that samples taken from the dairy tested positive do not prove that the unpasteurized milk was the source, though detection of the same serotype in patients and the milk would be very strong evidence. However, the correlation between raw milk consumption and illness is hard to ignore.
There are sometimes suggestions that the pasteurization process is too severe. The process was originally designed to eliminate Salmonella, but was later modified to be slightly more rigorous to ensure that Coxiella burnetti (a rickettsia-like organism which is the cause of Q-fever - a febrile disease of man and which sometimes has serious sequellae), was eliminated. There is currently some investigation of the time/temperature relationships in milk pasteurization to see if there is a possibility of making the process less severe.
Sunday, December 10, 2006
To pasteurize or not?
Over the past few weeks the issue of milk pasteurization has exercised the people and government of Ontario.
The argument is not a new one: some people believe that the practice of milk pasteurization destroys the nutritional characteristics of the milk and reduces its value as a food. The official line is that the sale (or even giving) of raw milk to the public is illegal, though it is permitted with varying restrictions in 28 states in the USA. Pasteurization of milk has been mandatory in Ontario since 1938. Earlier, around 1900, over 10% of all childhood tuberculosis was thought to be caused by unpasteurized milk. The rate of tuberculosis infection and many other milk-borne diseases in children fell dramatically after the law enactment and was hailed as a major achievement.
To understand the reasons given for pasteurization, we need to go back to the source of milk. Most of our milk supply comes from cows, though goats and sheep are also milked commercially. All of these animals carry bacteria in their intestines and on their skin and feet. They may also carry viruses internally. Some of these micro-organisms can infect humans, occasionally with very serious consequences. Examples are Listeria monocytogenes, Salmonella, Campylobacter, Mycobacterium tuberculosis, Eschericia coli, Brucella and Staphylococcus aureus.
Inside the udder of a healthy animal, the milk is essentially sterile. However, even in a well-run milking shed, it is very difficult to prevent some contamination of the milk from the exterior of the udder. A quick check of the filters will often show a small amount of dirt or fibrous material that has originated either in the gut or on the hide of the cow. Bacteria are too small to be seen with the naked eye, but will be present in the material in the filter and the milk stream. We have to accept that raw milk will contain bacteria and possibly faecal viruses.
All of these micro-oganisms are destroyed by heating the milk to 72C for 15 seconds.
Proponents of raw milk consumption (and the manufacture of cheeses etc. from unpasteurized milk) claim that pasteurization also destroys enzymes in the milk that aid in digestion of the product; the cheeses have less flavour and are inferior compared with their unpasteurized counterparts. I don't intend to get into a debate in this post about nutrition - I am not a nutritionist. So, I will list the effects of just some of these micro-organisms on the human body and leave you, the reader, to do your own nutritional research.
Listeria monocytogenes rarely affects healthy adults; those at high risk include pregnant women, newborn infants, the elderly, and those with weak immune systems. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimate that 2,500 people become seriously ill each year in the United States and among these, 500 will die. According to research, pregnant women account for 27% of these cases. CDC claims that pregnant women are 20 times more likely to become infected than non-pregnant healthy adults. Babies may be stillborn or infected at birth. Refrigeration will not stop this micro-oganism from growing, though its growth rate will slow.
Salmonella causes abdominal cramps, diarrhoea, vomiting, headache and elevated temperature when the bacterial cells invade the mucosal cells of the gut. The acute symptoms usually last for only one to two days, though some patients show a much longer illness. Chronic consequences may include arthritic symptoms developing some 3-4 weeks later. Obviously, during the diarrhoeal phase, contamination of the environment and thus other family members can occur.
Campylobacter jejuni is now regarded as the leading cause of gastrointestinal illness in many countries. See earlier posting "So what is this Campylobacter thing?"
Mycobacterium tuberculosis is probably a human-specialised form of M. bovis, which was probably passed to humans from cattle when milk consumption began. There is archaeological evidence that this occurred between 4000 and 8000 years ago and then spread through the migrations of Indo-Europeans throughout the world ( www-micro.msb.le.ac.uk). The normal transfer route is through droplets released during coughing, but tuberculosis can also be transmitted in foods, including unpasteurized milk. If M. tuberculosis reaches the lungs and sets up infection, lung damage results in the longer term if an inflamatory response occurs.
Escherichia coli are found in the gut of man and animals. Microbiologists have always known that some strains of these micro organisms can cause diseases, such as "Travellers' diarrhoea". However, we now know that many strains can cause disease, some life-threatening. There also seems to be an increase in the distribution of these pathogenic strains in farmed animals, as we see from the number of recently reported cases of E.coli O157:H7 in 5 states in USA.
E. coli O157:H7 infection often causes severe bloody diarrhea and abdominal cramps that may last for 5 to 10 days. In some people, particularly young children and the elderly, the infection can also cause hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS), in which the red blood cells are destroyed and the debris causes kidneys failure. About 8% of patients may develop HUS. Sometimes the patients recover after a long illness, but a significant number of children have required kidney transplants.
Brucella species are passed between animals in many countries, but can also affect humans. Unpasteurized cheeses, often called "Village Cheeses" sold in the Mediterranean Basin, Central America, Eastern Europe, Asia, Africa, the Caribbean and the Middle East may be the source of infection for travellers. The disease may produce flu-like symptoms - fever, sweating, headache, back pain, and physical weakness. However, severe infections of the central nervous systems or heart lining may occur. Brucellosis may also manifest as "undulant fever", a recurrent fever accompanied by joint pain and fatigue.
Staphylococcus aureus produces a heat-stable toxin when it grows in foods. The toxin usually causes vomiting and the effect may become apparent within 30 minutes of consuming the affected food. Diarrhoea may also be present. The symptoms do not usually last for more than 1-3 days and are not life threatening (though those suffering the symptoms may wish that it could be all over!)
The argument is not a new one: some people believe that the practice of milk pasteurization destroys the nutritional characteristics of the milk and reduces its value as a food. The official line is that the sale (or even giving) of raw milk to the public is illegal, though it is permitted with varying restrictions in 28 states in the USA. Pasteurization of milk has been mandatory in Ontario since 1938. Earlier, around 1900, over 10% of all childhood tuberculosis was thought to be caused by unpasteurized milk. The rate of tuberculosis infection and many other milk-borne diseases in children fell dramatically after the law enactment and was hailed as a major achievement.
To understand the reasons given for pasteurization, we need to go back to the source of milk. Most of our milk supply comes from cows, though goats and sheep are also milked commercially. All of these animals carry bacteria in their intestines and on their skin and feet. They may also carry viruses internally. Some of these micro-organisms can infect humans, occasionally with very serious consequences. Examples are Listeria monocytogenes, Salmonella, Campylobacter, Mycobacterium tuberculosis, Eschericia coli, Brucella and Staphylococcus aureus.
Inside the udder of a healthy animal, the milk is essentially sterile. However, even in a well-run milking shed, it is very difficult to prevent some contamination of the milk from the exterior of the udder. A quick check of the filters will often show a small amount of dirt or fibrous material that has originated either in the gut or on the hide of the cow. Bacteria are too small to be seen with the naked eye, but will be present in the material in the filter and the milk stream. We have to accept that raw milk will contain bacteria and possibly faecal viruses.
All of these micro-oganisms are destroyed by heating the milk to 72C for 15 seconds.
Proponents of raw milk consumption (and the manufacture of cheeses etc. from unpasteurized milk) claim that pasteurization also destroys enzymes in the milk that aid in digestion of the product; the cheeses have less flavour and are inferior compared with their unpasteurized counterparts. I don't intend to get into a debate in this post about nutrition - I am not a nutritionist. So, I will list the effects of just some of these micro-organisms on the human body and leave you, the reader, to do your own nutritional research.
Listeria monocytogenes rarely affects healthy adults; those at high risk include pregnant women, newborn infants, the elderly, and those with weak immune systems. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimate that 2,500 people become seriously ill each year in the United States and among these, 500 will die. According to research, pregnant women account for 27% of these cases. CDC claims that pregnant women are 20 times more likely to become infected than non-pregnant healthy adults. Babies may be stillborn or infected at birth. Refrigeration will not stop this micro-oganism from growing, though its growth rate will slow.
Salmonella causes abdominal cramps, diarrhoea, vomiting, headache and elevated temperature when the bacterial cells invade the mucosal cells of the gut. The acute symptoms usually last for only one to two days, though some patients show a much longer illness. Chronic consequences may include arthritic symptoms developing some 3-4 weeks later. Obviously, during the diarrhoeal phase, contamination of the environment and thus other family members can occur.
Campylobacter jejuni is now regarded as the leading cause of gastrointestinal illness in many countries. See earlier posting "So what is this Campylobacter thing?"
Mycobacterium tuberculosis is probably a human-specialised form of M. bovis, which was probably passed to humans from cattle when milk consumption began. There is archaeological evidence that this occurred between 4000 and 8000 years ago and then spread through the migrations of Indo-Europeans throughout the world ( www-micro.msb.le.ac.uk). The normal transfer route is through droplets released during coughing, but tuberculosis can also be transmitted in foods, including unpasteurized milk. If M. tuberculosis reaches the lungs and sets up infection, lung damage results in the longer term if an inflamatory response occurs.
Escherichia coli are found in the gut of man and animals. Microbiologists have always known that some strains of these micro organisms can cause diseases, such as "Travellers' diarrhoea". However, we now know that many strains can cause disease, some life-threatening. There also seems to be an increase in the distribution of these pathogenic strains in farmed animals, as we see from the number of recently reported cases of E.coli O157:H7 in 5 states in USA.
E. coli O157:H7 infection often causes severe bloody diarrhea and abdominal cramps that may last for 5 to 10 days. In some people, particularly young children and the elderly, the infection can also cause hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS), in which the red blood cells are destroyed and the debris causes kidneys failure. About 8% of patients may develop HUS. Sometimes the patients recover after a long illness, but a significant number of children have required kidney transplants.
Brucella species are passed between animals in many countries, but can also affect humans. Unpasteurized cheeses, often called "Village Cheeses" sold in the Mediterranean Basin, Central America, Eastern Europe, Asia, Africa, the Caribbean and the Middle East may be the source of infection for travellers. The disease may produce flu-like symptoms - fever, sweating, headache, back pain, and physical weakness. However, severe infections of the central nervous systems or heart lining may occur. Brucellosis may also manifest as "undulant fever", a recurrent fever accompanied by joint pain and fatigue.
Staphylococcus aureus produces a heat-stable toxin when it grows in foods. The toxin usually causes vomiting and the effect may become apparent within 30 minutes of consuming the affected food. Diarrhoea may also be present. The symptoms do not usually last for more than 1-3 days and are not life threatening (though those suffering the symptoms may wish that it could be all over!)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)